MoneyPlainly

MoneyPlainly

Salary Negotiation Scripts

5 email templates you can copy, customize, and send today

1 Counter-Offer Response

When to Use This

You received a job offer but the salary is below your target range. You want to counter professionally without jeopardizing the offer.

Subject Line

Re: [POSITION] Offer - [YOUR NAME]

Email Body

Hi [HIRING MANAGER NAME],

Thank you so much for extending the offer for the [POSITION] role. I'm genuinely excited about the opportunity to join [COMPANY] and contribute to [SPECIFIC PROJECT OR GOAL].

After reviewing the full compensation package, I wanted to discuss the base salary. Based on my research into market rates for this role in [CITY/REGION], and considering my [X YEARS] of experience in [RELEVANT SKILL], I was hoping we could explore a base salary closer to $[TARGET AMOUNT].

I'm confident I can deliver strong results quickly, particularly in [SPECIFIC VALUE YOU BRING]. I want to make sure we start on a foundation that reflects the value I'll bring to the team.

I'm flexible and open to discussing the full picture, including any sign-on bonus, equity, or other components. I'd love to find a number that works for both of us.

Looking forward to your thoughts.

Best,
[YOUR NAME]

Follow-Up Timing

Wait 2-3 business days. If no response, send a brief follow-up: 'Hi [NAME], just wanted to check in on my note about the compensation package. I'm still very excited about the role. Let me know if you'd like to discuss further.'

2 The Raise Request

When to Use This

You have been at your current job for 12+ months and believe you deserve a raise based on your contributions and market data.

Subject Line

Request for Compensation Discussion

Email Body

Hi [MANAGER NAME],

I'd like to schedule some time to discuss my compensation. I've been in my role for [TIME PERIOD] and want to make sure my pay reflects my current contributions and the market.

Here is a quick summary of what I've accomplished since my last review:

- [ACCOMPLISHMENT 1 with specific numbers/results]
- [ACCOMPLISHMENT 2 with specific numbers/results]
- [ACCOMPLISHMENT 3 with specific numbers/results]

Based on market data from [SOURCE: Glassdoor, Levels.fyi, Payscale], the range for my role and experience level in [CITY] is $[LOW] to $[HIGH]. I'm currently at $[CURRENT SALARY], which puts me [below/at the lower end of] that range.

I'd love to discuss adjusting my compensation to $[TARGET], which I believe reflects both the market and the value I'm delivering. Would you have 20-30 minutes this week or next to chat?

Thank you for your time.

Best,
[YOUR NAME]

Follow-Up Timing

If they say 'budgets are tight,' ask: 'When is the next budget cycle, and what can I do between now and then to position myself for an adjustment?' Get the answer in writing via a follow-up email.

3 The Competing Offer

When to Use This

You have received an offer from another company and want to use it to negotiate with your current employer. Use this carefully; only play this card if you are genuinely willing to leave.

Subject Line

Request for a Quick Chat

Email Body

Hi [MANAGER NAME],

I wanted to have an honest conversation with you. I've been approached by another company and, after going through their process, they've extended an offer at $[AMOUNT] for a [TITLE] role.

I want to be straightforward: I love working here. I value my team, the work we're doing on [PROJECT], and the culture at [COMPANY]. My preference is to stay.

That said, the gap between my current compensation ($[CURRENT]) and this offer is significant enough that I need to take it seriously. I wanted to give you the opportunity to discuss whether there's room to close that gap before I make a decision.

I don't need an answer today, but I do need to respond to their offer by [DATE, typically 1 week out]. Could we find time to talk this week?

Thank you for understanding.

Best,
[YOUR NAME]

Follow-Up Timing

Important: Only use this if you are genuinely prepared to accept the other offer. If your employer cannot match it, be ready to leave gracefully. Never bluff with a competing offer.

4 The Promotion Ask

When to Use This

You are already doing work above your current level and want formal recognition through a title change and raise.

Subject Line

Discussion: Growth Path and Role Alignment

Email Body

Hi [MANAGER NAME],

I'd like to discuss my growth path and how my current responsibilities align with the next level in our organization.

Over the past [TIME PERIOD], my role has evolved significantly. I'm now regularly:

- [RESPONSIBILITY 1 that's above your current level]
- [RESPONSIBILITY 2 that's above your current level]
- [RESPONSIBILITY 3 that's above your current level]

When I compare this to the [NEXT LEVEL TITLE] job description, there's substantial overlap. I believe I'm already operating at that level and would like to discuss formally transitioning to a [NEXT LEVEL TITLE] role with compensation aligned to $[TARGET RANGE].

I've put together a brief document outlining how my current work maps to the next-level expectations. Would you have time this week to review it together?

I'm committed to continuing to grow here and want to make sure we're aligned on the path forward.

Best,
[YOUR NAME]

Follow-Up Timing

Bring a one-page document mapping your current work to the job description for the next level. Concrete evidence is more persuasive than general statements.

5 The Benefits Negotiation

When to Use This

The company has told you the salary is firm and cannot be adjusted. Negotiate other parts of the compensation package instead.

Subject Line

Re: [POSITION] Offer - Additional Discussion

Email Body

Hi [HIRING MANAGER NAME],

Thank you for the update on the salary. I understand the constraints and I appreciate your transparency.

Since the base salary is set at $[AMOUNT], I'd like to discuss a few other elements of the package that could help bridge the gap:

- Sign-on bonus: A one-time bonus of $[AMOUNT] to offset the difference in my first year
- Equity/RSU: An additional equity grant of [AMOUNT/SHARES]
- Remote flexibility: [X] days per week remote or fully remote
- PTO: An additional [X] days of paid time off
- Professional development: A $[AMOUNT] annual budget for conferences, courses, or certifications
- Title adjustment: [PROPOSED TITLE] to better reflect the scope of the role
- Review timeline: A guaranteed compensation review at [6 MONTHS] instead of the standard annual cycle

I don't expect all of these, but even one or two would make a meaningful difference. Which of these might be possible to discuss?

Looking forward to your thoughts.

Best,
[YOUR NAME]

Follow-Up Timing

Prioritize your list before sending. Know which 1-2 items matter most to you. Companies are often more flexible on non-salary items than you expect, especially sign-on bonuses and review timelines.

moneyplainly.com

Customize these templates for your specific situation. Replace all [BRACKETS] with your actual information before sending.